Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Theological and political impact of the Council of Nicaea on Christianity

Overview
Council of Nicaea was organised on 325 C.E. by the order of Constantine 1 by the recommendation of a synod led by Hosius of Córdoba. In the council the Nicaean creed was developed to battle against Arianism, so the nature of Christ (p.b.u.h.) was determined. The day of celebration of Passover (Ester) was also determined. It is said that 1800 bishops including both from east and west were invited for the council, while only about 270 – 318 bishops attended. “1t is significant that no one from the Church of Donatus was asked to attend – although Cacealian, Donatus's chief opponent, was invited.” (Rahim and Thomson, 1995, p96). Debates in the council continued from 20th May to 19th June of 325 C.E.
Theological impacts
1. The nature of Christ
One of the main purpose of the Council of Nicaea was to eradicate the unitarian belief which many Christians had at that time in the name of resolving the disagreement which arose within the Church of Alexandria regarding the relationship between the Son and Father. Trinitarians of Pauline Church wanted to impose manifestation of God in the Father, Son and the Holy Spirit, without any evidence from their scriptures. Large controversy arose between Unitarians like Arians and Trinitarians. Finally homoousian of father and the Son was affirmed the Trinitarian belief was accepted as the fundamental doctrine and termed as the official Christianity. The decision was made by majority vote. Jesus Christ (p.b.u.h.) was declared as the only begotten Son of the Father – begotten, not made. “Of those who signed the Nicene Creed, some believed in it, some pretended to believe in it, even though they did not really know what they were putting their names to, and some, the majority of the delegates at the Council, did not agree with the doctrine of Trinity at all, but nevertheless signed the Creed with silent mental reservation, in order to please the Emperor.” (Rahim and Thomson, 1995, p104). Emperor decided that anyone who refused to believe in Nicaean creed would be exiled and excommunicated.
2. Celebration of Easter
According to Christians the crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus (p.b.u.h) was at the same time as the Jews passover. However they believed that the time Jews celebrated passover was miscalculated as the month Nisan was before spring equinox. Some of them wanted to compute to determine Nisan to set Easter separately as in recent times Nisan never preceded equinox, while others thought it would be wise to keep the traditional reliance on the Jews calender, even though the computation of Jews were wrong. Independent computation of Nisan on a Sunday in a lunar month chosen according to Christian criteria was affirmed and the controversy was solved. Those who urged to keep according to Jews calender followed the majority
3. Canons of doctrinal orthodoxy
Original number of Gospels at the time of Council of Nicaea was unknown. According to some reports there are at least 270 versions or perhaps as many as 4000 different Gospels were there. According to Rahim and Thomson these Gospels were placed under a table in the Hall of Council and the door was locked. At that night Bishops prayed to find most reliable Gospels on top of the table and in the morning they found Matthew, Mark, Luke and John there. Twenty new Church laws called canons were also promulgated in the Council of Nicaea.
4. Others
Romans considered their Emperor as the representation of sun-god in the earth. So the Pauline Church declared Roman sun day to be the Sabbath of Christians. Birthday of sun-god – 25th of December – was considered as the birth day of Jesus. Cross – the emblem of sun-god – was also adopted as the symbol of Christianity.
Political Impacts
Soon after the Council of Nicaea Arius, Theonas, and Secundus who strongly opposed the Nicaean creed were exiled to Illyria and excommunicated. The Council of Nicaea increased the differences between the Christians sects. To restore unitary among Christians over a million Unitarians were prosecuted. Obeying the ruling of the Pauline Church was made mandatory. Even though Nicaean Creed was an agreement on profession of belief, the conflicts and controversies among the sects which were there before the Council continued. Perhaps only the Athanasius was loyal to it.
In 328 C.E. after the death of Bishop Alexander, strong fight for post arose between the Arians and Meletians, but Athanasius was declared as a bishop, who was accused of persecution, political intrigue and even magic.
On other hand the Emperor's sister expressed her great regret against prosecution which the Unitarian Christians were facing. She also opposed the banishing of Eusebius of Nicomedia due to his beliefs. So Eusebius was finally allowed back and it was a great blow to the Athanasian. As a result the Emperor lean towards the side of Arius. When he heard the dispute on the election of Athanasius, new Bishop was summoned to the capital. However Athanasius made excuses and did not go to Constantinople.
The First Synod of Tyre was called by Emperor and a letter was sent to Athanasius that if he refuse to come he would be brought to the Synod forcibly. The disapproval of Athanasius was confirmed by the bishops gathering in Jerusalem. Finally Arius was invited to the Constantinople, taken back into the Church and allowed to receive communion. In desperate Athanasius came to the Constantinople and Emperor granted him audience and Eusebius of Nicomedia was also present in it. He accused Athanasius of hindering the supply of corn to the Constantinople from Egypt. As the charge was proven, Athanasius was exiled to Trier in Gaul while Arius was appointed as the Bishop of Constantinople. He died soon after in 336 C.E. Emperor suspected it to be a murder. Athanasius was found to be guilty, and was condemned for poisoning Arius. The Emperor was heartbroken by the death of Arius. He was baptised by Eusebius of Nicomedia and died a year later, in 337 C.E.

Reference
  1. Got Questions, Got Questions Ministries, ....... , What occurred at the Council of Nicea? [Online], available at http://www.gotquestions.org/council-of-Nicea.html, Accessed on 17th December 2014, 10:15 am
  2. Wikipedia the free encyclopedia, last editied by Gabby Merger (2014), First Council of Nicaea [Online], Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Council_of_Nicaea, Accessed on 16th December 2014, 13:05
  3. Wikipedia the free encyclopedia, last edited by Special Contributions 24.187.148.244 (2014), First Synod of Tyre [Online], Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Synod_of_Tyre, Accessed on 17th December 2014, 19:55
  4. 'Ata'ur-Ramm, M and Thomson, A (1995) Jesus Prophet of Islam (Revised Edition), Ta-Ha Publishers Ltd [Online], Available at http://wynnechambers.co.uk, Accessed on 17th December 2014, 10:32 am


No comments:

Post a Comment